DAMMS opposes STDC’s demand
IMPHAL| Mar 13
Delhi Association of Manipur Muslim Students (DAMMS), New Delhi has urged the Scheduled Tribe Demand Committee (STDC), Manipur to look into the “Unclarity” in its demand for the Meitei/Meetei community in the Scheduled Tribe list under the Indian Constitution.
Stating that indigenous people’s movement has taken place all over the world where there are “oppressed, conquered and colonised people,” a release from the Association said that Manipur has also recently seen the rise of indigenous people’s movement in the demand for Inner Line Permit (ILP). “However, the demand for the rights of indigenous people has now shifted to the demand for the inclusion of Meiteis in the ST list,” it said while stating that the theoretical explanation of the shift is that the indigenous people are the same as tribals in the Indian context.
Asserting that Indian academicians and the government of India (GOI) do not acknowledge the category of indigenous people, the release contended that the understanding of the word ‘Tribal’ according to International Labour Organisation (ILO) says that “Tribal people also retain some or all of their social, economic, cultural and political institutions, irrespective of their legal status” as an argument to back up DAMM’s allegation that the demand for the inclusion of the Meiteis in the ST list is a forced equation that indigenous peoples are tribals. “Yelhoumi” which translates as indigenous is now forced to mean tribal given the limitation imposed by the Indian Constitution, it added.
DAMM also stated that “The Meitei Pangals (Manipuri Muslims) have settled in Manipur since the early 17th century even before the Brahmin migration in the Imphal Valley; and there is no denying that both Pangals and Bamons are indigenous to the Manipur valley.”
While contending that the listing of both Pangals and Meiteis in the same category as Other Backward Classes (OBCs) is problematic given the vast economic and economic and social equality between the two communities, the release argued that the demand of the STDC leaves the Meitei Pangal community in a precarious state. It further asserted that if the Pangals remain OBC and Meiteis become ST, then it would mean that Meiteis are less economic and socially capable than Pangals while adding that the Meitei Pangal community is one of the most marginalised communities in the State.
The release also argued that even though it is unclear whether the Meitei-Loi communities who are already in the Scheduled Caste list will be listed under ST if the demands of STDC are met, the same problem persists if they are not listed under ST because SC is above ST in the general social and economic hierarchy in India. It asserted that the “Meitei Bamons” and “Rajkumar Sageis” have oppressed and ruled the Meiteis, and their listings as STs are the confusions involving the demand while adding that the demand of STDC has evoked strong opposition from the Nagas and Kukis who are already in the ST list.
The Manipuri Muslim students association, in its release, further proclaimed that the concern of the Nagas and Kukis are justified stating that a section of the various communities residing in Manipur being included in the ST list matters to the others. “The STDC should acknowledge that its demand is creating suspicion and tension between the different communities in the State while also disturbing the communal harmony,” it added.
Given the “Unclarity” of the STDC’s demand, DAMMS additionally urged the Committee to acknowledge the principle of social justice and the relationship underlying the Categories and the responsibility that one committee has towards other when it comes to social justice and harmony.
IMPHAL | Mar 20 President of All India Congress Committee (AICC), Rahul Gandhi has assured that the Congress party will never allow the “unique identity, culture, history of the people of Manipur” to be jeopardised under any circumstances. Rahul Gan.....
THOUBAL| Mar 20 Even though seven individuals had obtained registration forms, no candidates have filed their election forms for the Outer Manipur (ST) parliamentary constituency elections yet. More importantly, the Returning Officer had issued a notif.....
IMPHAL | Mar 20 “Extra Judicial Execution Victim Families Association Manipur (EEVFAM) along with civil voluntary organisations will launch intense forms of agitations for delivering justice to fake encounters victims.” This was stated by general se.....
IMPHAL | Mar 20 On the occasion of Yaoshang festival, state top officials Governor Najma Heptullah and chief minister Nongthombam Biren Singh and Speaker Yumnam Khemchand has extended their heartiest greetings to the people of Manipur. Governor on h.....
IMPHAL | Mar 20 President, All Manipur Bar Association, senior advocate, H. Chandrajit Sharma today submitted his resignation letter to the association over allegations of professional misconduct reportedly raised against him. A resignation letter i.....