Memories of wounds: how much to forget
Trauma history has a tendency of haunting its subjects for a long time, sometimes causing serious psychological hurdles for entire societies in coming to terms with what 19th century Danish philosopher Soren Kierkegaard said in one of his most quoted lines: “Life can only be understood backwards; but it must be lived forwards”.
History has not always been kind to the Northeast region. A traditional world abruptly found itself confronting British colonial administration after the Treaty of Yandaboo 1826 which ended Burmese occupation of Assam and Manipur. Assam under the British was almost the entire Northeast with the exceptions of Manipur and Tripura. Assam was annexed and made a province of Bengal but Manipur was left as a protectorate, though with a purpose.
The British then evolved an ingenious mechanism to administer the region, demarcating it broadly into ‘administered areas’ consisting largely of the fertile productive plains much of which were already under organised centralised bureaucracies of feudal States, and ‘un-administered areas’ of wild, sparsely populated mountainous territories beyond the plains, where tribes untouched by modern ways lived.
In 1873 the Bengal Eastern Frontier Regulation was introduced to draw an ‘Inner Line’, to demarcate the two regions. The very next year, conceding to demands by a growing Assamese middleclass, Assam was separated from Bengal to become a chief commissioner’s province. The rise of Assamese linguistic nationalism is engaging, but another story.
The Inner Line was the British Administration’s answer to tackling non-State spaces they encountered in the Northeast. Although these territories beyond the line were claimed as British possessions, they were not administered, except for occasional punitive military expeditions. Protectorates States like Manipur were used in the control of these non-State spaces.
The Government of India Act 1919 classified the territories beyond the Inner Line as ‘Excluded Areas’ and they were left out of the provincial legislature introduced by the Act. They were instead kept under the charge of the Governor of the province. The Government of India Act 1935 reclassified some parts of the ‘Excluded Areas’ as ‘Partially Excluded Areas’. These were given some representation in the provincial legislature but by nomination of the Governor and not election. This administrative structure is what India inherited in 1947.
Much of the vexed politics of identity in the Northeast today is predicated by this past and bear close resemblance to the frictions within what Willem Schendel called ‘Zomia’ and James Scott elaborated in his influential book ‘Art of Not Being Governed: An Anarchic History of Upland South East Asia’. Zomia corresponds with the wild mountainous massif of South East Asia inhabited by once primitive tribes, interspersed by fertile valleys where agricultural surpluses led to emergence of ‘Paddy States’.
In modern times, when the ‘non-State-bearing’ populations of Zomia awoke to State consciousness, they found themselves already part of other States. This is at the crux of most of the endemic identity entangles in the region. In the cases of principalities which were States already, the circumstances of the merger with India is often the sore point.
The question is, how much of this past must the Northeast bid adieu to so its road to the future is unfettered. Freud’s Mourning and Melancholia provides some insights. In Mourning, the mourner does not allow the space between him and his loss to collapse. The commitment is, while not forsaking the memory of the dead, the living must move on. Melancholia on the other hand becomes a narcissistic engagement in which the mourner begins to take perverse pleasure in the fact of his mourning, thereby perpetuating the grieving. The second is often where the Northeast is.
Take Manipur for which September is a cruel month. September 13 is observed as Black Day by Kukis, commemorating those of the community killed in the Naga-Kuki clashes in the 1990s. September 21 is bandh day enforced by Meitei rebel groups to protest the signing of the Merger Agreement with the Indian Union in 1949 by Maharaja Bodhchandra Singh under house arrest at Shillong during a visit. Must these remembrances continue to be about opening up old wounds to bleed further or should they be about mourning to come to terms with the losses and then look to future challenges and prospects?
In this onerous task of sublimating collective past traumas, the calibre of politics in the hands of characteristically dishonest, law-manipulating political leadership has not helped. The current BJP government in the state for instance returned only 21 seats in the 60-member Assembly in March 2017, but wrested power with the help of Congress defectors. One and a half years later, one of the defectors is a cabinet minister and the other six sit in the opposition benches but vote with the treasury. Yet the 10th Schedule which requires such defectors to seek fresh mandates has not been invoked. Such brazen disregard of rule of law at the very top expectedly has only embittered rather than restore faith of the people in the system.
(This article appeared first in The Telegraph under a different heading)
IMPHAL | Jul 19 Decrying the Manipur Services (Revision Pay) Rules, 2019 notified by the government on July 11 and demanding reasonable pay scale, more than 10,000 teachers inclusive of higher secondary lecturers, primary teachers and graduate teachers.....
Matter listed by High Court fails to make it in cause list IMPHAL | Jul 19 A petition filed by Imphal Free Press (IFP) in the High Court of Manipur, pertaining to defamation case filed by the Chief Minister, which was supposed to be listed for heari.....
IMPHAL | Jul 19 Following the mysterious death of a girl student inside the boarding room of Standard Robarth Higher Secondary School, Canchipur, Socialist Students’ Union of Manipur (SSUM) imposed a shutdown on the school, from Saturday. A class 7 .....
IMPHAL | Jul 19 Demanding that the culprits involved in the mysterious death of Ningthoujam Babysana Chanu must be booked, JAC formed against the death along with locals staged a sit-in-protest today at Thangmeiband area opposite THAU ground. Speaki.....
IMPHAL | Jul 19 Khudrakpam Kendra Youths Organisation (KHUKYO) has alleged the officials and authority of Dolaithabi barrage project that it has failed to deliver its promises and that these officials are also avoiding to meet the villagers. Secreta.....